Loading... Please wait...

Cheese

Sort by
  • Salted Butter, 16 oz.
    Trickling Springs Creamery; from grass-fed cows. Pure butter plus Celtic sea salt.
  • [butter_unsalted]
    Trickling Springs Creamery; from grass-fed cows.
  • [goat butter]
    Trickling Springs Creamery; from grass-fed goats.
  • [cheddar]
    Byers' Dairy; Cheddar cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • [english cheddar]
    Keswick Creamery; English-style creamy cheddar, aged 4 months, with a black wax rind. This is 'the good stuff!' (Raw milk)
  • [dill & chive cheddar]
    Byers' Dairy; Cheddar cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, with added dill and chives, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • garlic herb cheese
    Byers' Dairy; Cheddar cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • [colby]
    Byers' Dairy; Colby cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • [smoked colby cheese]
    Byers' Dairy; Smoked Colby cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • [gouda cheese]
    Byers' Dairy; Gouda cheese made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • [baby s]
    Byers' Dairy; Swiss cheese (sorry, no holes!) made with the Byers' organic milk from their herd of grass-fed Jersey cows, by a cheesemaker in Honey Brook, PA. (Raw milk)
  • Blue Suede Moo Cheese, ~4 oz.
    Keswick Creamery; very tasty, funky blue cheese. And yes, that's how it's supposed to be. “Get down, everybody...” (Raw milk)
  • [dragons breath]
    Keswick Creamery; fiery pepper-jack cheese. (Raw milk)
  • [italian herb feta]
    Keswick Creamery; Keswick's Jersey feta with added herbs.
  • Vermeer Cheese, ~8 oz.
    Keswick Creamery; Gouda-type cheese. (Raw milk)
  • [goat cheddar]
    Trickling Springs Creamery; cheddar-style goat cheese. (Raw milk)
  • [goat cheese curd, PIPE DREAMS]
    Pipe Dreams Dairy; soft, spreadable goat cheese curd. (Pasteurized.)
  • [goat cheese tom basil]
    Little Antietam Goat Dairy; soft, spreadable goat cheese curd. (Pasteurized.)

Sign up for our newsletter

View Cart Go To Checkout